WebMay 30, 2006 · Toolan told Tom Lochtefeld about Beth helping him with business contacts. But Toolan was evasive about his employment. And Beth's brother wasn't convinced that Toolan actually had a job. At one … WebOct 28, 2004 · Yesterday, as Nantucket residents dealt with the jolting news of the island's first murder in more than 20 years, the former boyfriend, Thomas E. Toolan III, was ordered held without bail in Rhode ... the stables surgery

Sleeping jurors cited in Nantucket slaying appeal - Boston.com

In the first trial, his attorney at the time, Kevin Reddington, argued that Toolan was not criminally responsible, or not legally sane, at the time of the murder. In that case, a jury found Toolan guilty of first-degree murder in just under four hours. All first-degree murder convictions are automatically appealed, and the … See more Toolan's appeal is still pending with the state's highest court, according tothe SJC docket. In 2024, he was granted a stay by the court as he … See more While the legal case is pending, Toolan's story has been covered by several documentary-style TV shows including Dateline NBC and "Sins & Secrets," which can be viewed on Amazon Prime andDiscovery+. A … See more WebSep 24, 2024 · The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court reaffirmed the conviction of Thomas Toolan, who was convicted of murdering a woman on Nantucket in 2004 WebAug 23, 2011 · The Supreme Judicial Court said in its decision released on Tuesday that there were flaws in the way the jury for the trial of Thomas Toolan III was selected, … the stables swinhoe